Guides
How to spot the saboteur
The saboteur holds real clues and reads them out like everyone else. You catch them by what breaks, not by who looks nervous.
Watch for a broken board
Every wrong option is ruled out by some clue, and the true answer is never ruled out. If your case board ever shows zero suspects left standing, or one place both cleared and confirmed, a clue somewhere is false. Ask the last three readers to repeat theirs word for word.
Five habits of good detectives
- Write down who read which clue. A note next to each crossed-off suspect saves arguments later.
- Ask people to read clues exactly, not summarise them. Summaries are where lies hide.
- Notice who argues hardest for a theory that only one clue supports.
- Notice who clears a suspect that nobody was looking at.
- Hold a hint back for round 3. A hint crosses off an option that is definitely wrong, and it cannot lie.
Voting
The team's verdict is the most popular pick in each category, and a tie counts as no answer. Agree as a group before locking in, so the saboteur cannot win by splitting the vote. Name your saboteur suspect honestly: correctly naming them earns the Saboteur Spotter badge.
Questions
Can there be two saboteurs?
No. A case has at most one saboteur.
What if we get the answer right but miss the saboteur?
The case still counts as solved. Naming the saboteur is a separate bonus for the detectives who got it.